A Brief History of Rob Reiner’s Impossible Streak

Every year, in that weird week after Christmas and before New Year’s, I fall into the same void most people know all too well. The leftovers turn gray in the fridge. The phone sits silent. The wind rattles the windows. All I can think to do is watch movies and let time drift until something feels like a reason to get out of bed.

This year, it was Rob Reiner who gave these aimless days some meaning.

Most people know Reiner as the man behind some of the biggest films of the 1980s and early '90s. He was a Broadway-raised kid whose father was Carl Reiner – the comedy legend who helped create The Dick Van Dyke Show and shape American TV comedy. The son learned from the master, but he wasn’t content to stay in his father’s shadow. Before he was a director, he was Meathead on All in the Family – a liberal foil in a sitcom that defined a generation. Eventually, he turned the camera around, and Hollywood didn’t know what hit it. 

His first feature as a director was This Is Spinal Tap. On the surface, it's a movie about a fictional heavy metal band. If you watch it again, you see it is so meticulously crafted that when it came out, some people didn’t even realize it was a mockumentary. In the early ‘80s, there were no social media reveals, no rooftop press conferences to explain what was real and what wasn’t. Radio stations booked the band for interviews. Concert promoters inquired about the tour dates. Journalists wrote about Spinal Tap like they were covering a real band. The film was shot like a documentary, edited like one, and played like one, making absolute believers out of anyone who came in cold. In doing so, the movie essentially invented the modern mockumentary format and set the template for everything from Christopher Guest’s ensemble comedies to TV shows that pretend they are airing real life. Reiner even appears on camera as the documentarian — a choice that showcased his comic instincts and his sense of how to blur reality and fiction in a way that feels completely lived in.

Right after Spinal Tap came The Sure Thing. It is easy to skip past because it sits before the giants, but this is where you can feel Rob Reiner becoming Rob Reiner. On the surface, it is a teen road trip comedy. Underneath, it is a modern echo of Frank Capra’s It Happened One Night, not a remake so much as a spiritual handoff. Capra had train stations and chivalry. Reiner has cheap diners, hitchhiking, and arguments that start as jokes and accidentally turn into something honest.

This is the first time his emotional geometry shows up. Two people stuck together in cars and motels, orbiting each other like planets that have not decided whether to crash or connect. He lets scenes breathe. He holds the camera on a face just long enough for embarrassment to turn into recognition. It feels like the early DNA of When Harry Met Sally, the idea that conversation can be its own special effect.

The Sure Thing is not a masterpiece. It is the doorway. It is the rehearsal for what comes next.

What came next was Stand By Me, which turned out to be the moment the curtain actually rose.

If The Sure Thing was rehearsal for emotional storytelling, Stand By Me was opening night. Reiner took Stephen King’s novella The Body and turned it into something timeless because he treated the story and the actors with extraordinary care. The film’s casting was deliberate. Reiner and the producers auditioned more than 70 boys before finding the four leads who felt like real friends rather than just performers. Before cameras rolled, he put them together for two weeks of improv games to build trust and camaraderie. That bond shows on screen as much as any line of dialogue.

Reiner cared about these kids beyond their talent. Jerry O’Connell, who was 11 years old when he played Vern Tessio, has spoken openly about how much Reiner meant to him. Years after filming ended, Reiner heard O’Connell was in Los Angeles and took him out to lunch just to catch up and encourage him, telling him how proud he was of his work. O’Connell later said that kind of affirmation meant everything to him as a young actor still finding his footing.

On set, his compassion showed in the way he worked with all four boys. Wil Wheaton, Corey Feldman, and Jerry O’Connell have all recalled Reiner creating an environment where they felt protected and supported. Instead of treating them like small versions of adults, he let them be themselves, helped them bond, and gently guided them when needed. That care seeped into every frame of the movie and helped make it one of the most beloved coming-of-age films ever made.

Stand By Me was more than a movie for Reiner. It was a project where he gave these young actors a sense of confidence and belonging that stayed with them long after the cameras stopped rolling. That deep human connection helped cement the film’s emotional core and made it one of the defining works of his early directing run.

If Stand By Me was proof that Reiner could handle emotion, the next stretch was proof he could shape culture. First came The Princess Bride – a movie that feels like it stumbled out of a dream but was actually built with ridiculous precision. It reads like a fairy tale for kids, but has the timing, melancholy, and wit of a film made for adults, sneaking grief into their popcorn. Reiner pushed to shoot it in real locations whenever possible. Real fields. Real forests. Practical effects. Steel and fabric and wind. The kind of filmmaking that feels like it was carved by hand instead of assembled on a soundstage. It made fantasy feel intimate again, like something that could breathe.

Then came When Harry Met Sally – the film that quietly rewired the modern romantic comedy but also served as a love note from Reiner to his own wife. The script by Nora Ephron originally had Harry and Sally walking away from each other at the end. That was the plan until Reiner met his future wife, Michelle Singer, on the set. Their connection changed his world, and it changed the movie. The final ending, in which Harry chases Sally down and confesses his love, wasn’t in the original outline. It became real because his real life became part of the imagination behind the camera.

That personal investment gives the movie its beating heart. It feels handwritten in places, as if Reiner is whispering the things you never knew you needed to hear. The film also incorporates a bit of a documentary spirit. The interspersed interviews with real couples — old lovers who have stayed together and strangers who have just met — make the movie feel like it is examining love from both sides at the same time. It feels less like escapism and more like anthropology, like someone holding a mirror up to the way people actually talk, fight, and forgive each other.

When Harry Met Sally is not a film that announces itself as groundbreaking. It is two people talking in diners, apartments, parks, and sidewalks. Reiner treats those conversations like set pieces. The combustion happens in the pauses, in the almost-confessions, in the moments where you recognize yourself on the screen. In early test screenings, women laughed first, and men followed later, as if they needed permission before they could admit they understood the joke.

Reiner never softened the edges of the story. He treated romance like architecture that needed to be built correctly, not a throwaway genre. It is the moment his run stops looking accidental and starts looking inevitable: one of the sharpest, warmest romantic comedies ever written that also feels like a love letter written out in real life.

This is the point where he becomes undeniable.

After reinventing romance and fantasy, Rob Reiner pulled an abrupt left turn into darkness with Misery. Based on Stephen King’s 1987 novel, the film stars James Caan as Paul Sheldon – a novelist who survives a car wreck only to be held captive by a crazed fan who claims to adore his work. Reiner worked with William Goldman on the screenplay, and from the first day of casting, it was clear he wanted tension that came from character and psychology instead of jump scares. Kathy Bates was not yet a household name when he cast her as Annie Wilkes, but he saw something in her reading that made him confident she could carry the role. The movie stayed focused on the claustrophobia and unpredictability of the relationship between captor and captive, and it paid off. 

The film became a critical and commercial success upon its release in late 1990, earning praise for its gripping tension and the performances of its leads. Most importantly, Bates won the Academy Award for Best Actress for her portrayal of Annie Wilkes, making Misery the only Stephen King adaptation ever to win an Oscar. That achievement was remarkable not just because of the genre restrictions — horror and thriller films rarely translate into Academy Awards — but because Bates beat out established names in her field that year. 

Reiner himself was famously skeptical that the Academy would reward a performance anchored in horror conventions, but he always supported Bates’ work and encouraged her to trust her instincts. Over time, this role became a defining turn in her career and a testament to Reiner’s ability to coax deep, intense performances from his performers.

Misery feels like another turning point, one where Reiner demonstrated his ability to apply emotional precision not only to comedy and romance but also to dread and terror while still giving the core performances space to breathe.

After the airtight horror of Misery, Reiner moved straight into the courtroom with A Few Good Men. It was another genre shift that should have broken the streak, but instead it continued the impossible momentum. Adapted from Aaron Sorkin’s play, the film feels like a pressure chamber. Every scene is about oxygen and who controls it. Tom Cruise as the lawyer who still needs to grow up. Demi Moore as the conscience no one wants to acknowledge. Jack Nicholson as the gravity in the room. Reiner directs them all like a boxing match where everyone throws words instead of punches.

The film became a cultural landmark the second Nicholson spoke, “You can’t handle the truth.” That line got printed on T-shirts, whispered by college kids, quoted in arguments, imitated by comedians, and eventually fossilized into movie history. A lot of directors would have leaned on the quote and let it do the work. Reiner built the pressure that makes the line detonate. He trusts the script. He trusts the actors. He trusts silence. It is the same emotional confidence from When Harry Met Sally and the same precision from Misery, repurposed for a room full of uniforms.

When the credits roll, the run is complete:
Mockumentary that birthed a genre.
Road movie that rediscovered romance.
A coming-of-age film that feels like a memory.
A fantasy that feels hand-carved.
A romantic comedy that rebuilt its own blueprint.
A horror film with an Oscar at its center.
A courtroom drama that burned into our culture.

Six years. Seven films. No missed steps. 

From Our Sponsors

What do Tom Brady, Alex Hormozi, and Jay Shetty all have in common?

They all have newsletters.

If you’re building a personal brand, social can only take you so far. Algorithms glitch. Reach tanks. But a newsletter gives you real ownership and revenue.

That’s why we built a free 5-day email course that shows you how to grow and monetize with sponsorships, digital products, and B2B services.

Usually we charge $97, but for the next 24 hours it’s free. Sign up for the course today.

Get the course 100% free

Forrester Expert Webinar - AI Enters the Content Workflow Conversation

Find out how to manage and monetize your content library on January 14th as industry pioneers from Forrester Research and media executives formerly of ESPN, Disney, and Comcast reveal how to get on the cutting edge of content operations with the help of AI.

Save my seat